Unstrung News Analysis

N+I: Noise Report

LAS VEGAS -- The show floor at this year's Networld+Interop exhibition may be spookily quiet, but the air between the booths is filled with noise.

Radio noise, that is. As predicted, 802.11 is everywhere at the trade fair this year, and that means interference is also all around, providing a foretaste of what a world full of 802.11 could really be like (see N+I: Congestion Problems?).

Trapeze Networks Inc. is in the thick of it, running a private 802.11a (54-Mbit/s over 5GHz) network in one of the central exhibition halls. "I ran Netstumbler [a cult network sniffing application] and there must be 45 access points out there," Brian Bailey, a product marketing type for the startup, told Unstrung. "And they're all committing every kind of sin."

Sadly -- despite the fact that this is Vegas -- Bailey only means that the access points are using overlapping radio channels and performing all kinds of other heinous deeds that make RF engineers (but few others) go weak at the knees.

Normally, running a 5GHz 802.11a hotspot takes an access point out of the crowded 2.4GHz band inhabited by the much more popular 802.11b standard. However, "there's quite a bit of a stuff running here," Bailey notes. He says Trapeze did some "sneaky stuff" with its switch to ensure the network ran smoothly, but your Unstrung correspondent couldn't access the members-only Trapeze network to see whether their efforts were successful (see Trapeze's High Wireless Act for more on Trapeze's technology).

In fact, a lot of the WLAN equipment vendors have rented nearby hotel suites to talk to the press and run demos. Of course, this is partly because of economic necessity -- it's cheaper to rent a room than a big booth at the show.

However, as Blaine Kohl, VP of marketing at Bandspeed Inc. observes (from the comfort of an airconditioned suite overlooking the Nevada desert): "Its difficult to do any kind of meaningful demonstration [of this technology] down there." (See Startups Add to Switch Mix for more on Bandspeed.)

— Dan Jones, Senior Editor, Unstrung

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
Dan Jones
User Ranking
Tuesday May 6, 2003 12:36:13 PM
no ratings
There was a lot of em:

Airespace
Aruba
Chantry
Trapeze

etc.

Really hard to any kind of performance analysis or anything like in the context of N+I

DJ
airbb
User Ranking
Monday May 5, 2003 11:55:35 AM
no ratings
How was Interop?
Can you give us the summary as far as wireless switches are concerned?
no ratings
This would explain why my feet hurt!

Dan
no ratings
Just spoke with the LV Convention Center authority. Turns out, LV Convention Center has about 2 million square feet.

Just as a point of reference, if at the last show, they would have had a WLAN network powered by CWN's TRUErate technology, and since data throughput scales directly with the size of the coverage area, then the total aggregate data throughput provided by TRUErate
would have been approximately 8 Gigabits per second. If 108 Mbps. raw data rate was used instead of the current 54 Mbps. then the aggregate available data throughput would have been in the 16 Gigabits per second range. If data compression was also present further increases in data throughput would have resulted.

TRUErate technology allows us to do something that no other WLAN technology allows you to do, the ability to overlap cell coverage areas without causing any interference, ad infinitum, allowing for densely populated AP infrastructures.

As hard as this may be to believe, this technology exists and has been verified both algorithmically and through various simulations.

dbeberman
User Ranking
Wednesday April 30, 2003 10:03:02 AM
no ratings
TRUErate the solution to the N+I WLAN Noise problems

It looks like the WLAN noise problems at the N+I show in L.V. Nevada are the classic problems that occur when there are multiple overlapped 802.11 Access Points, and multiple and varying number of users. The wireless network becomes congested and the amount of available real data throughput becomes unreliable. I would think this does play havoc with anybody’s live wireless demonstrations at the minimum.

Corporate WaveNet’s TRUErate directly addresses this problem by allowing all of the Access Points to cooperatively share the network without causing congestion. Further, the varying number of users at any moment in time does not have any effect on the congestion of the network. With the addition of TRUErate’s zero-overhead QoS facility, bandwidth can be provisioned for various classes of users. This might enable pay-for-service wireless networking at tradeshows, for example.

In real numbers, if we assume that each tradeshow floor is approximately 150,000 sq. ft. (I don’t know the exact dimensions of the LV floors), and that there are 2 tradeshow floors, a TRUErate deployment can deliver aggregate 1.2 Gpbs. of sustained real application data throughput, using the current 802.11 modulation schemes. When 802.11n delivers the promised 108 Mbps. then the aggregate throughput would jump to 2+ Gbps. In a fully deployed system, the sustained throughput would be available throughout the tradeshow floors with no deadspots, regardless of the number of wireless LAN users or their locations.

TRUErate can enable locations such as tradeshow floors to go completely wireless for virtually all of their data communications needs. Please visit www.corporatewavenet.com for more information.

David Beberman

UNSTRUNG MARKET PLACE
Windows Server® 2008 R2 - Free Download
Reduce Costs & Increase Efficiencies Across Your Enterprise. Download Today!
VoIP For Dummies - Get a Free Copy
Find out how VoIP works, business advantages & the 3 phases to VoIP migration
SIP Trunking Advantages & Applications
Learn how SIP works and the benefits of implementation. Free white paper by XO®
Master Your Asset Retrieval
OnProcess helps leading companies return inventory faster, saving $$Millions
Used and Refurbished Cisco Routers
Purchase Your Routers From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Unstrung. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
Events
Cable Next-Gen Broadband Strategies: Docsis 3.0, Wireless, Fiber & Beyond
Thursday, February 25, 2010
The Cable Center, Denver
Tower Technology Summit
March 23- 25, 2010
Las Vegas Convention Center, Las Vegas
Ethernet Europe
Monday & Tuesday, April 12 & 13, 2010
London Marriott Hotel Grosvenor Square, London
OSS Virtual Event
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Companies
Alltel (102), Apple (453), Aruba Networks (97), AT&T (formerly Cingular) (910), Cisco (875), Clearwire (328), Google (418), Intel (696), Juniper (148), Microsoft (509), Motorola (1299), Nokia (1882), NTT DoCoMo (483), Palm (294), Qualcomm (500), Research In Motion (RIM) (344), Sprint Nextel (966), Symbol Technologies (169), T-Mobile (533), Texas Instruments (206), Verizon Wireless (808), Vodafone (1243)

Fixed/Mobile Convergence
ATM (10), Backhaul (51), Circuit Switch (13), Copper (3), Core Network (412), DWDM (6), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Ethernet (36), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Frame Relay (1), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) (28), IPv6 (15), Media Gateways (19), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microwave (69), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Management (98), Mobile VPNs (61), MPLS (8), Packet Switch (109), Sales Force Apps (43), Session Border Controllers (3), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Sonet (8), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), WiMax (33), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Handhelds
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), iDEN (74), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microbrowsers (66), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Univeral Mobile Telecommunications Service (UMTS) (1283), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Applications
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Applications (940), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Workforce
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microbrowsers (66), Middleware (54), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile/Wireless System (OS's)
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Webpads (93)

RFID
Bluetooth (246), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Mobile Management (98), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Vertical Apps (235)

Telco Wireless
802.16 (587), Access Points (722), Base Station Controller (BSC) (243), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) (780), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), iDEN (74), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), OSS/Billing/CRM (646), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Ultrawideband (UWB) (140), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN Switches (480)

WiMax/Broadband Wireless
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.16 (587), 802.20 (66), Antennas (63), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), Fixed WiMax (212), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), HiperLAN (11), Home Base Stations/Femtocells (392), Mobile WiMax (805), WiMax (751), Wireless Broadband (722)

Wireless VOIP
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Smartphones & Handsets (2047)

WLANs/WiFi/802.11
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.11 Single Chips (SOC) (39), Access Points (722), Antennas (63), Base Station Controller (BSC) (243), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Baseband Controller (49), Comms Chips & Wireless Components (1297), HiperLAN (11), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), Multimedia Mobile Access Communication (MMAC) (17), Power Amplifiers (75), Public Access Hotspots (986), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Security (404), Smart Antennas (61), Wireless LAN (1217), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN cards (119), WLAN Switches (480)