Unstrung News Analysis

T- Mobile Busts Backhaul Bottleneck

T-Mobile International AG is taking the HSDPA backhaul bottleneck challenge head-on with the commercial launch of an Ethernet-over-DSL solution from RAD Data Communications Ltd. (See T-Mobile Ramps Up Backhaul, T-Mobile's Backhaul Bugbear , and HR Tracks Backhaul.)

By deploying an Ethernet-over-DSL solution, T-Mobile is ahead of the pack as many operators are considering Ethernet-based backhaul to increase capacity in the transport network at a lower cost than deploying many expensive E-1 leased lines. (See Ethernet Backhaul Battle Brews, Carriers Face Backhaul Conundrum, Mobile Backhaul Peaks in 2007, Mobile Carriers Tackle Backhaul Bottleneck, and 3G Drives Backhaul Spending.)

RAD first announced T-Mobile as a customer back in May last year. But now, the German giant has confirmed the success of field trials of RAD's ACE-3000 gateway. T-Mobile has been backhauling commercial high-speed downlink packet access (HSDPA) traffic over the gateway in Germany since late October last year. (See T-Mobile Picks RAD and RAD Tackles HSDPA Transport.)

T-Mobile is also testing the solution in two other European markets, one of which is the U.K., according to Gaby Junowicz, business development director at RAD.

With RAD's backhaul gateway in Germany, T-Mobile uses ADSL2+ lines, which are supplied by Deutsche Telekom AG (NYSE: DT)'s fixed-line business T-Com , to transport HSDPA traffic from the radio access network to the mobile core.

According to Junowicz, T-Mobile has deployed hundreds of the gateways and plans to use them as the backhaul solution for its entire HSDPA network in Germany as well as other European markets.

"Wherever they have HSDPA networks, they will use our solution," says Junowicz. "HSDPA would be dead in the water without this kind of solution. It just wouldn't be possible."

T-Mobile has rolled out HSDPA, with downstream speeds of up to 7.2 Mbit/s, across its 3G network in Germany, Austria, and the Netherlands, according to a spokesman. The operator plans to deploy high-speed uplink packet access (HSUPA) -- which will boost the upstream data speeds to 1.4 Mbit/s -- across the German 3G network by the middle of this year. (See T-Mobile Deploys HSUPA.)

The first mobile operator to go commercial with RAD's Ethernet-based backhaul solution was Japan's 3G operator eMobile Ltd. late last year. (See RAD Wins in Japan.)

"They were a Greenfield [3G] operator and had no GSM network… so they had to be profitable from day one from HSDPA," says Junowicz.

— Michelle Donegan, European Editor, Unstrung

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
Gabriel Brown
User Ranking
Friday January 18, 2008 4:23:00 AM
no ratings
Much of the DSL being considered for backhaul is better than consumer grade. There are even specialist suppliers proposing to use unbundled copper pairs in some markets (UK, for example). It depends on if you can actually get unbundled copper at the cell site…. That's not always possible in some countries/regions. Beyond that, there are a ton of other things that come into play. (Sync, QOS, reliability, reach, regulation, etc).

T-Mob presented this DSL backhaul concept at our Backhaul Strategies event in Berlin last June. Obviously, it's well thought through.

Like el rupester said, the DSL physically layer is used for E1/T1. Others are proposing to use it for mid-band Ethernet backhaul.

Anything that gives lower cost per bit will help lower the cost of HSPA services to end users and spark innovation in mobility applications.

We're just in the early phases of exploiting HSPA and EV-DO from a services perspective. That's what makes it fascinating.
el rupester
User Ranking
Thursday January 17, 2008 2:40:39 PM
no ratings
There is no fundamental (technological) reason DSL cannot deliver high quality. Indeed T1 and E1 services have been delivered by HDSL for years.

As Gabriel says, the is is quality/cost. If you wanted to, (if you wanted to pay for it) you could negotiate with a landline operator to get "carrier grade ADSL". I wonder if TMO has done this?

Much of the pressure on backhaul capacity is data. You can squeeze a lot of AMR voice sessions into just one E1, after all.

Yes, ADSL is asymmetric. But then again, so is data traffic. This is not a coincidence. I have a HSDPA PCMCIA card that promises 7.2Mbps downlink, and 300Kbps uplink...

Gabriel Brown
User Ranking
Thursday January 17, 2008 10:03:16 AM
no ratings
Hi postar

It would require a long post (or some paid research!) to address your question.

In essence, with DSL you’re trading quality for lower cost… there are lots of carriers both for and against it. Uplink capacity is not the only or even main concern.

That T-Mobile has gone for it in a biggish way in Germany is interesting. Presumably the services are of the high quality you’d expect. It'll be interesting to see if it validates the model for others.
postar
User Ranking
Wednesday January 16, 2008 10:46:15 AM
no ratings
As I see it, using ADSL to backhaul mobile NodeBs does have a big disadvantage.

ADSL is asymmetric, 3Mbps max on the uplink.
NodeBs are usually configured with n x E1.

Isn't this a bottle neck?!
UNSTRUNG MARKET PLACE
Master Your Asset Retrieval
OnProcess helps leading companies return inventory faster, saving $$Millions
Free Guide by XO® : VoIP For Dummies
Find out how VoIP works, business advantages & the 3 phases to VoIP migration
Used and Refurbished Nortel Routers
Purchase Your Routers From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
Used and Refurbished Cisco Routers
Purchase Your Routers From Network Liquidators. Savings of Up to 90% with a Lifetime Warranty!
Online Webcast: Unified Computing-Part 2
Learn the way to a more efficient & simplified data center. Register for 2/10/10
The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Unstrung. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
Events
Cable Next-Gen Broadband Strategies: Docsis 3.0, Wireless, Fiber & Beyond
Thursday, February 25, 2010
The Cable Center, Denver
Tower Technology Summit
March 23- 25, 2010
Las Vegas Convention Center, Las Vegas
Ethernet Europe
Monday & Tuesday, April 12 & 13, 2010
London Marriott Hotel Grosvenor Square, London
OSS Virtual Event
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Webinars
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Companies
Alltel (102), Apple (453), Aruba Networks (97), AT&T (formerly Cingular) (910), Cisco (875), Clearwire (328), Google (418), Intel (696), Juniper (148), Microsoft (509), Motorola (1299), Nokia (1881), NTT DoCoMo (483), Palm (294), Qualcomm (500), Research In Motion (RIM) (344), Sprint Nextel (966), Symbol Technologies (169), T-Mobile (533), Texas Instruments (206), Verizon Wireless (808), Vodafone (1243)

Fixed/Mobile Convergence
ATM (10), Backhaul (51), Circuit Switch (13), Copper (3), Core Network (411), DWDM (6), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Ethernet (36), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Frame Relay (1), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) (28), IPv6 (15), Media Gateways (19), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (717), Microwave (69), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Management (98), Mobile VPNs (61), MPLS (8), Packet Switch (109), Sales Force Apps (43), Session Border Controllers (3), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Sonet (8), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), WiMax (33), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Handhelds
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), iDEN (74), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (717), Microbrowsers (66), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Univeral Mobile Telecommunications Service (UMTS) (1283), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Applications
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (717), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Applications (940), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Workforce
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (717), Microbrowsers (66), Middleware (54), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile/Wireless System (OS's)
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Webpads (93)

RFID
Bluetooth (246), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Mobile Management (98), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Vertical Apps (235)

Telco Wireless
802.16 (587), Access Points (722), Base Station Controller (BSC) (242), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) (780), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), iDEN (74), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), OSS/Billing/CRM (646), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Ultrawideband (UWB) (140), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN Switches (480)

WiMax/Broadband Wireless
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.16 (587), 802.20 (66), Antennas (63), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), Fixed WiMax (212), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), HiperLAN (11), Home Base Stations/Femtocells (392), Mobile WiMax (805), WiMax (751), Wireless Broadband (722)

Wireless VOIP
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Smartphones & Handsets (2047)

WLANs/WiFi/802.11
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.11 Single Chips (SOC) (39), Access Points (722), Antennas (63), Base Station Controller (BSC) (242), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Baseband Controller (49), Comms Chips & Wireless Components (1297), HiperLAN (11), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), Multimedia Mobile Access Communication (MMAC) (17), Power Amplifiers (75), Public Access Hotspots (986), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Security (404), Smart Antennas (61), Wireless LAN (1217), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN cards (119), WLAN Switches (480)