Sequans Ad
Jonestown
Dan Jones

The Mobile Duopoly

April 28, 2009 | Dan Jones | Comments (3)
no ratings

Is there any operator that, in the foreseeable future, can crack the hegenomy of AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T) and Verizon Wireless as the top two wireless carriers in the U.S.?

If there is, I haven't figured out which one it is yet.

AT&T and Verizon's subscriber additions even tend to track each other closely in recent quarters. For instance, Verizon Wireless added 1.3 million retail wireless customers in the first quarter this year, just beating AT&T's 1.2 million net adds in the same period.

Verizon had a total subscriber base of 86.6 million at the end of the first quarter, while AT&T had racked up 78.2 million wireless subscribers by then. The big two's nearest rival, Sprint Nextel Corp. (NYSE: S), has been losing subs recently and ended 2009 with 49.3 million on its books, while fourth-place T-Mobile USA added just 415,000 subscribers in the first quarter.

3:00 PM -- So, it seems unlikely that any of AT&T and Verizon's traditional rivals have a way of adding enough new customers to surpass the big two right now. It is possible, in these recessionary times, that we could see more savage price cuts to wireless services, but smaller rivals such as MetroPCS Inc. (NYSE: PCS) and Leap Wireless International Inc. (Nasdaq: LEAP) seem to have been making the most of the early running in the low-cost market so far.

An upstart like Clearwire LLC (Nasdaq: CLWR), meanwhile, needs years to build up customers, services, and a network to present a viable challenge to the big two. The mobile WiMax challenger may never actually get that far.

There is always the possibility of outside carriers becoming more of a factor in the U.S. market. SK Telecom (Nasdaq: SKM) has been rumored to be sniffing around Sprint in the past, for instance.

Nontheless, in the short-term, I don't see what other operator could be the downfall of this mobile duopoly. In fact, barring antitrust worries, AT&T and Verizon seem better placed to pick off more small carriers to try and extend their customer bases.

Of course, it won't be this way forever. That would be as foolish as suggesting, say, that a run-up on housing prices would continue indefinitely. Still, in the next three to five years -- and likely longer -- AT&T and Verizon seem destined to remain the top dogs of cellular America.

— Dan Jones, Site Editor, Unstrung

Newest Comments First       Display in Chronological Order
omniobso
User Ranking
Thursday April 30, 2009 1:49:24 PM
no ratings

Take a good look at the technological underpinings of Sprint.  They are the direct beneficieries of Clearwire's 'wireless ethernet backhaul stratagy'.  The deployment and cost of the Wimax buildout are moving VERY rapidly.  There will probably be no announcements of what is operable (mobile wimax) for obvious strategic reasons.  However, the grapevine is reporting receiving the signal in many, many locations that are not listed in their 'rollout schedule'. 

Sprint's capex has been lightened appreciably by shifting it to Clearwire; and, although, we won't see their numbers until Monday morning, I think we're in for a sizable surprise.  Boost, from the 'buzz' has sizzled and their wholesale positions with retailers, such as Amazon's Kindle, are proliferating.

The entire closed, 2 year contract, subsidy, business model is dead!  With tech cycles shortening by the day, and the 'open hand set alliance' proliferating like rabbits; we're going see a new wave led by Sprint (aka Intel, Google, Cisco, etc.).

Like everybody else, it's just speculation, but if you do some digging, I think you'll find it to be accurate.

 

 

Dan Jones
User Ranking
Thursday April 30, 2009 12:33:45 PM
no ratings

Okay, which carrier can do it? Do you think Clearwire can grow fast enough based on their microwave architecture?

 

DJ

omniobso
User Ranking
Thursday April 30, 2009 12:22:35 PM
no ratings

Your post could probably rank right up there with past commentators on Penn Central, General Motors ad nauseum.  The antiquated 'backhaul infrastructure of AT&T and VZ are based on obsolete T1s.  Wireless broadband ethernet links toll the eventual death nell of the 'big two'.  In case you haven't heard; change is accelerating, at least according to Einstein!

The blogs and comments are the opinions only of the writers and do not reflect the views of Unstrung. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
More Jonestown
iPad: The Touch of Death?
4:00 PM Rumors of the death of the mobile Web are greatly exaggerated
Apple iPad Unveiled
1:50 PM Still waiting for news on wireless connectivity options
The Hilarity of LTE iPhone Rumors
3:05 PM If an LTE iPhone is coming in Q2, where are the networks?
Sprint / Wal-Mart WiMax Conundrum
8:45 AM Rumors suggest that Sprint is working on a WiMax tower deal with Sprint, wait just a second there...
How Closely Could Google Watch Nexus One Users?
2:00 PM iSuppli ponders Nexus One user tracking by Google
Events
Cable Next-Gen Broadband Strategies: Docsis 3.0, Wireless, Fiber & Beyond
Thursday, February 25, 2010
The Cable Center, Denver
Tower Technology Summit
March 23- 25, 2010
Las Vegas Convention Center, Las Vegas
Ethernet Europe
Monday & Tuesday, April 12 & 13, 2010
London Marriott Hotel Grosvenor Square, London
OSS Virtual Event
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Webinars
White Papers SPONSORED CONTENT
Featured
Companies
Alltel (102), Apple (453), Aruba Networks (97), AT&T (formerly Cingular) (910), Cisco (875), Clearwire (328), Google (418), Intel (696), Juniper (148), Microsoft (509), Motorola (1299), Nokia (1882), NTT DoCoMo (483), Palm (294), Qualcomm (500), Research In Motion (RIM) (344), Sprint Nextel (966), Symbol Technologies (169), T-Mobile (533), Texas Instruments (206), Verizon Wireless (808), Vodafone (1243)

Fixed/Mobile Convergence
ATM (10), Backhaul (51), Circuit Switch (13), Copper (3), Core Network (412), DWDM (6), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Ethernet (36), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Frame Relay (1), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) (28), IPv6 (15), Media Gateways (19), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microwave (69), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Management (98), Mobile VPNs (61), MPLS (8), Packet Switch (109), Sales Force Apps (43), Session Border Controllers (3), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Sonet (8), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), WiMax (33), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Handhelds
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) (1540), Handheld Computers (379), iDEN (74), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microbrowsers (66), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Univeral Mobile Telecommunications Service (UMTS) (1283), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Applications
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Mobile Data Gateways (104), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Applications (940), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile Workforce
Bluetooth (246), Email/Personal Information Management (403), Finance & Banking (85), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Handheld Computers (379), Message Gateways (SMS, MMS) (718), Microbrowsers (66), Middleware (54), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Databases (30), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Mobile VPNs (61), Sales Force Apps (43), Security (293), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Vertical Apps (235), Webpads (93), Wireless Web Gateways (WAP, i-mode) (105)

Mobile/Wireless System (OS's)
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Mobile .Net (15), Mobile Devices (790), Mobile Java(J2ME) (104), Mobile Management (98), Mobile Operating Systems (Pocket PC, Palm, EPOC, RIM) (318), Smartphones & Handsets (2047), Webpads (93)

RFID
Bluetooth (246), Global Positioning System (GPS) (121), Mobile Management (98), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Shop-Floor Apps (23), Vertical Apps (235)

Telco Wireless
802.16 (587), Access Points (722), Base Station Controller (BSC) (243), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) (780), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), iDEN (74), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), OSS/Billing/CRM (646), Service Gateways(GGSN/PDSN) (163), Ultrawideband (UWB) (140), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN Switches (480)

WiMax/Broadband Wireless
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.16 (587), 802.20 (66), Antennas (63), Enhanced Data GSM Environment (EDGE) (405), Fixed WiMax (212), General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) (613), HiperLAN (11), Home Base Stations/Femtocells (392), Mobile WiMax (805), WiMax (751), Wireless Broadband (722)

Wireless VOIP
Email/Personal Information Management (403), Fixed Mobile Convergence (335), Handheld Computers (379), Smartphones & Handsets (2047)

WLANs/WiFi/802.11
802.11 Chipsets (282), 802.11 Single Chips (SOC) (39), Access Points (722), Antennas (63), Base Station Controller (BSC) (243), Base Transceiver Station (BTS) (281), Baseband Controller (49), Comms Chips & Wireless Components (1297), HiperLAN (11), IEEE 802.11 (a,b,g) (1190), Multimedia Mobile Access Communication (MMAC) (17), Power Amplifiers (75), Public Access Hotspots (986), Radio (RF) Chips (79), Security (404), Smart Antennas (61), Wireless LAN (1217), WLAN Bridges (71), WLAN cards (119), WLAN Switches (480)